Tales & Co.COACHING
N 41.0082° · E 28.9784° · Istanbul
← Perspective
Field Notes

Preparing for General Manager Means Giving Up a Side

Executives preparing for general manager tend to study the functions they don't know. The real preparation is moving from arguing one side to deciding between them.

7 min readNovember 2026

Preparation for general manager usually starts from the wrong gap

In early conversations with a senior executive preparing for a general manager role, the talk usually opens with a list of gaps. The candidate from sales says they don't know finance, the one from finance says operations, the one from operations says customers. The list makes sense, and the preparation plan follows from it: a finance programme, a rotation through operations, an executive course. The candidate usually writes the list through the eyes of the people who will choose them, from what they expect the board to see as missing.

The gap is the seat, not the knowledge

None of these plans is wrong, but most of them miss the real difference. What separates a general manager from a functional head is not the breadth of what they know. It is where they sit at the table. A functional head comes to the leadership meeting as the representative of one side; they argue for their function's share of budget, priority and people, and they rise because they argue it well. A general manager is the person at the same table who decides between the sides. Preparing for general manager is less about learning new fields than about learning to move from advocate to arbiter.

No programme teaches that move, because it is a change of habit rather than of knowledge. A mind that has spent years working to make one side win does not start looking evenly on its own. It is also the least discussed part of the preparation, and candidates usually notice it at the first serious dispute, at a moment when everyone is watching them. Which jobs build that habit, years before the seat, is the subject of how general managers are made.

A new general manager's first test is a decision about their old function

A pattern we meet often in coaching begins with an executive promoted from sales director to general manager. The preparation has been careful: a finance course finished, a few weeks spent in production, a seat at board presentations. A few weeks after the appointment, the first serious dispute reaches the table. Sales wants a custom delivery schedule for a large customer; operations says it will disrupt the line for months.

The home function

Everyone in the room is watching for the same thing: whose side the new general manager will take. If the decision goes to sales, operations reads it as a leaning and concludes that the general manager is still the sales director with a bigger title. If it goes to operations, the sales team concludes that their old boss has abandoned them. Neither reading is about the content of the decision. Both are about who made it.

The general manager in this pattern looked for a middle path instead of making the call. Sales got part of its schedule, operations got part of its line, and each side was told the other had given ground. The meeting ended calmly. A few weeks later the same dispute came back with a different customer, because nobody had heard a rule being set. A middle path is sometimes the right decision; chosen to avoid showing whose side one is on, it only moves the decision to the next meeting.

The first cost of arbitrating

What new general managers in this pattern find hardest is deciding against their own former function. The people they worked alongside for years know they are understood, and they say so. A general manager's neutrality is not established by declaring it; it is established by the first decision that goes against the function they came from. The longer that decision takes to arrive, the more lasting the other functions' view of them as a party becomes.

A functional head comes to the table to represent one side. A general manager sits at the same table to decide between them.

Preparation starts by retaking the table's recent disputes as the arbiter

Last quarter's contested decisions

That is why our work with an executive preparing for general manager starts not with a course catalogue but with last quarter's leadership meetings. The candidate writes down five or six decisions on which two or more functions disagreed. Against each one they add three things:

  • which side they argued in that decision, and on what grounds
  • what they would have decided from the general manager's seat
  • what that decision would cost the losing function, and how they would tell its head

The second column often comes out the same as the first, and that is the first finding. Believing they were looking as the arbiter, the candidate has rewritten the same argument in broader language. The exercise starts to work once the two columns begin to come apart.

Which decisions go on the page matters too. The ones a candidate remembers best are usually the ones their own function won. So we build the list from the meeting notes rather than from memory, and we always add one or two disputes between two other functions in which the candidate never spoke. On those lines the candidate decides for the first time with no side to argue, and sees more clearly what arbitrating feels like.

The decision against your own side

There is one line we look for on the page: the line where the candidate, as general manager, would decide against their own function. If there is no such line, either their function was never in the wrong last quarter or the candidate cannot yet look that way. The second is far more likely. A candidate who can make the decision that costs their own function on paper can make it at the table; one who cannot make it on paper usually chooses to defer it there. The third column matters as much, because the general manager's job is not only to decide but to hold that conversation with the head of the function that will carry the cost.

In unfamiliar functions a general manager owes the right question, not the answer

Questions instead of expertise

The list of gaps is not wasted; it just has to serve a different purpose. A general manager will never be a better finance person than the finance director, or a better operator than the head of operations. Nobody expects it. What is expected is the ability to ask each functional head what the thing they are arguing for will cost. A finance course is worth taking not so the candidate can explain a balance sheet line, but so they can question the assumption behind a budget request.

So in preparation we have the candidate write a short set of questions for every function they don't know: when that function's head brings a request to the table, which three questions bring out its real cost. Those questions teach faster than a curriculum, because they make the candidate look through the arbiter's eyes rather than the function's.

For a candidate from sales, the questions for an investment request from operations tend to look like this: which assumption has to fail for this investment not to pay back, in which quarter does it return, and what would the same money do in another function. None of them needs operational expertise. All three invite the head of operations to explain the request rather than defend it, and they establish the general manager's place at the table by showing what they look at, not whose side they are on.

The function left behind

The last and most often postponed part of the preparation is who takes over the function the candidate is leaving. A general manager without a ready successor stays on as the shadow head of their old function. The new director waits for their approval on every decision, and the team keeps taking questions straight to the general manager. A general manager who has not let go of their old function never fully establishes their neutrality at the table either. Successor preparation is therefore not an HR plan; it is part of the candidate's own preparation. The general stages of preparing for a promotion are covered in the piece on preparation starting before the title.

From the field

This subject usually enters the room as a training question. The candidate asks which programme to take, which field to learn, before becoming general manager. We turn the question around: in the last leadership meeting, on which decision would they have ruled against their own team, and how would they have told that team.

What happens in the room

The answer often starts with a pause. The candidate names a few decisions, explains why their function was right in each, and then notices how alike the explanations sound. From there the conversation turns from the list of gaps to the seat. How a new leader's first decisions get read once they are in the seat is the subject of the piece on a CEO's first 90 days. Preparing for general manager means learning to stop arguing one side and start deciding between them, before closing any gap in what one knows.

How we work begins with that question. Our other pieces sit on the Perspective page.

For executives preparing for general manager

Let's talk about the seat at the table before the list of gaps.

The first conversation starts not with a training plan but with last quarter's contested decisions, and where you stood on each.

Request a conversation
TALES & CO.   /   ENTERING
Click to enter
2026 · Vol I