Tales & Co.COACHING
N 41.0082° · E 28.9784° · Istanbul
← Perspective
Field Notes

How a Transformational Leader Behaves at the First Failure

Leaders asking how a transformational leader behaves look at the good days. The team reads them in the week someone tries the new way and stumbles.

7 min readNovember 2026

A transformational leader is read most closely the day after a failure

The question of how a transformational leader behaves usually reaches us in the language of good days. The leader thinks of an inspiring talk, an open door, time given to the team. None of that is wrong; but it is not the moment when the team watches the leader most carefully. That moment is the week the first person to try the new way the transformation asks for stumbles.

Transformational leadership is defined by the sentences a team forms about its leader, which is the argument of the piece on what transformational leadership is. Look at which events those sentences are built from, and the quiet weeks contribute less than one would expect. A team learns who its leader is mostly from the days when something goes wrong.

The new way works worse at first

Every transformation asks people to do something differently: to take a decision one level lower, to talk to customers through a new process, to share with another team work they used to finish alone. The old way has been mastered over years. Everyone knows where it breaks and what to do when it does. The new way is still clumsy, and in its first months it breaks more often than the old one. That is not a design flaw. It is what learning looks like.

So the first quarter of a transformation almost always produces visible mistakes, and some of them can be traced straight to the new way. A transformation asks people to accept working worse for a while, and they decide whether to accept it by watching how the leader responds to the first failure.

A failure on the old way counts as routine, a failure on the new way as evidence

A pattern we meet often in coaching becomes visible through two setbacks in the same quarter. The leader has usually launched the transformation personally, or was brought in to run it. They believe in the programme and follow it closely.

Two setbacks, two meetings

One director has kept working through the old process and missed the quarter's target. It gets five minutes in the weekly meeting: the market, a customer who slipped, a few adjustments for next quarter. Another director was among the first to try the new structure. They handed a decision to their team, and the team delivered two weeks late. That gets a meeting of its own. The leader asks what happened step by step, requests a written review, and opens the question of whether the new structure came too early for this team.

In the leader's own eyes they are simply being careful. Watching the first signals of a programme they care about feels like responsibility. The old way's setback is familiar and gets waved through. The new way's setback looks like information, and it seems worth examining.

What the team learns

The team draws a different conclusion from the same two events. The person who failed on the old way was discussed for five minutes; the person who failed on the new way became the subject of a meeting. Nobody says it aloud, but everyone does the arithmetic: trying the new way is riskier than staying on the old one. From then on the new structure lives on paper, decisions keep travelling the old channels, and everyone waits for someone else to go first.

The more a leader cares about the transformation, the more closely they examine failure on the new way, and the team reads that close attention not as interest but as risk. This is often exactly where a transformation stalls, and from outside it looks less like resistance than like waiting.

If a mistake on the new way costs more than a mistake on the old one, the team will decide that staying on the old way is the sensible choice.

A transformational leader treats the first failure as the price of trying

Facing the same setback, a transformational leader starts somewhere else. This is not leniency. The target stays where it was, the delay is called a delay, the deadline is renegotiated. What changes is what the leader takes the failure to be evidence of.

The way first, then the person

The leader's first question is not who got it wrong but whether the new way was tried as agreed. If it was, the setback is information about the new way: it shows which step was underdesigned and which team is not yet ready for what. If it was not, if the new way was half-applied and mixed with old habits, that is a different conversation. Without this distinction every failure goes into one bag, and the most visible one, the failure of whoever tried the new way, pays for the whole bag.

Taking on the cost

The second behaviour is harder. When the first failure on the new way is discussed, the transformational leader says plainly that they chose this way, that they knew setbacks like this would come in the first months, and that this is the price of the path. Then they hand the gap the setback exposed back to the team; the people who tried the new way write what has to change. A transformational leader books the first failure on the new way to their own account, as the one who chose the path, not to the person who tried it.

This does not mean turning a blind eye to the same mistake twice. The first failure is the price of learning. The same failure in the same place a second time is a lesson not learned, and it is discussed as one. Teams grasp that difference easily. A person who believes they were punished for trying the new way, on the other hand, does not object at the next step; they slow down, and how that quiet resistance can be read is the subject of the piece on resistance to transformation.

The asymmetry only shows when the failures are set side by side

Leaders find this pattern hard to see on their own, because each of their responses looks reasonable to them. Taken one at a time, a meeting called for the new structure's first delay is reasonable; so is a five-minute discussion of a target the old process missed. The pattern only appears when both events land on the same page.

A review of the last quarter

That is why the first piece of work we do with the leader is a short review. The last quarter's setbacks go into two columns: those on the old way and those on the new way. Against each one, three things are added:

  • the meeting and the time given to it
  • the first question asked afterwards: what happened, or who did it
  • the work the person who made the mistake was given in the weeks that followed

The page usually tells the leader something they did not expect. The rows in the new-way column are fewer but longer. The first questions point more often at a person, and some of those who made the mistakes have been quietly kept away from the next big piece of work. Each response to a failure looks reasonable to the leader at the time; the asymmetry only shows when the failures are set side by side.

Said before the failure

The step after the review looks forward. The leader anticipates which setbacks the transformation will produce in the coming quarter and tells the team in advance: failures of this kind are expected in the new way's first months, they are the price of the path, and nobody will pay for them for having tried. A failure named in advance is met, when it comes, not as a surprise but as an expectation fulfilled. And the team no longer has to wait for that day's meeting to guess what will happen to the first person who stumbles.

From the field

This subject usually enters the room as a complaint about ownership. The leader says the team has not embraced the new structure, that nobody takes the initiative, that everyone waits for their approval. They ask how a transformational leader behaves and look for a way to inspire more. We turn the question around: who last tried the new way and stumbled, and what happened to them the following week.

What happens in the room

The answer usually arrives as an event, and the event is usually small: a delayed delivery, a lost customer, a first meeting that went wrong. As the leader describes it, they also remember the meeting they gave it, the questions they asked, and the work the person was given next. At that point the conversation turns from inspiration to accounting. How a leader's attention divides between the picture and the people is covered in the piece on visionary and transformational leadership; the first failure is where that attention is tested. How a transformational leader behaves is settled not on the good days but on the day after the new way's first failure.

How we work begins with that question. Our other pieces sit on the Perspective page.

For leaders running a transformation

Let's talk about what happens after the first failure before inspiration.

The first conversation starts not with a new talk but with last quarter's setbacks, and what followed each of them.

Request a conversation
TALES & CO.   /   ENTERING
Click to enter
2026 · Vol I